Updated July 2026 · 7 min read
Part of the Nurse Money & Investing Hub — browse every related guide in one place.
Financial Disclaimer: This article is general educational information, not individualized financial, tax, or investment advice. Everyone's situation differs. Consult a fiduciary advisor or a tax professional before making decisions with real money.
Nurses meet annuities more than almost any other profession, for a historical reason: 403(b) plans — the retirement plan of hospitals and nonprofits — were originally only allowed to hold annuities, and the insurance companies that built that market never left. If your hospital plan is run by an insurer and your statement mentions a "variable annuity," "TSA," or "tax-sheltered annuity," this article is about your money. The short version: the annuity wrapper inside a retirement account usually adds cost without adding anything you need — but the fix is a form, not a catastrophe.
An annuity is an insurance contract, not an investment. In its purest form it does one clean job: you hand an insurer a lump sum, and it pays you a guaranteed income for life — insurance against outliving your money. That pure form (a "single premium immediate annuity," bought at retirement) is a legitimate, sometimes excellent tool, and it's the version economists actually like.
What lives inside hospital 403(b)s is different: the variable annuity, an investment account (mutual-fund-like "subaccounts") wrapped in an insurance contract. The wrapper adds a death benefit almost nobody uses (your heirs get at least what you contributed — relevant only after a market crash and your death before recovery) and, most importantly, adds fees.
| Fee layer | Typical range | What it's for |
|---|---|---|
| Mortality & expense (M&E) | 0.5%–1.3%/yr | The insurance wrapper itself |
| Subaccount expense ratios | 0.5%–1.5%/yr | The actively-managed funds inside |
| Administrative/contract fee | ~$30–$50/yr or 0.1%–0.3% | Recordkeeping |
| Optional riders (income guarantees) | 0.5%–1.5%/yr | Guarantees with fine print doing heavy lifting |
| Surrender charge (if you leave early) | Up to 7%, declining over 5–10 yrs | Recouping the agent's commission |
Stack the recurring layers and 2–2.5% per year is common — against ~0.04% for an index fund. As the expense-ratio math shows, a 2% annual drag over a 30-year nursing career consumes roughly a third to a half of your ending balance. That is the entire case, and it doesn't need exaggerating.
Ten minutes, one login: (1) If your 403(b) provider is an insurance company, suspect an annuity; if it's a brokerage/recordkeeper with mutual funds, you're likely fine. (2) Find the fee disclosure — the plan must provide a 404(a)(5) fee document; search your portal for "fee disclosure" or "prospectus." (3) Look for the words M&E, separate account, surrender, and rider. (4) Add every layer into one all-in percentage. Under ~0.5% total, relax. Over ~1.5%, you have a project.
First, check the menu. Many hospital plans offer several vendors side by side — an insurer legacy option and a low-cost index provider. Future contributions can usually be redirected with one form, and existing balances exchanged between vendors inside the plan with no tax event. Second, mind the surrender schedule. If moving the old balance triggers a 5% surrender charge that expires in 18 months, redirect new money now and move the balance when the charge lapses — the fee disclosure lists the schedule. Third, use the 90-24-style transfer or a rollover. After leaving a job, the whole balance can roll to an IRA at any low-cost brokerage, tax-free. Fourth, don't stop contributing out of disgust. Even an expensive annuity 403(b) with an employer match beats no match — capture the match, then optimize, in that order (the same rule as the funding order of operations).
Related: Expense ratios: the fee audit, 403(b) vs 457(b), Hospital pensions, and Target-date funds.
Get the ICU Notebook
Free investing strategies built for nurses. One email per week, no fluff.
Yes, send it freeNo spam. Unsubscribe any time.